Update: San Diego OB loses privileges

In an effort to share the information I’m receiving, here is the latest communication from Carol Yeh-Garner dated May 13 at 5:23pm.  Main points include:

• a list of 4 doctors who “are responsible for suspending Dr. Biter”
• how one of these doctors, as well as the head of OB at Scripps, will benefit financially from Dr. Biter’s suspension
• a summary of a meeting between 5 pregnant moms, 2 husbands,  Carol Yeh-Garner, the Scripps Chief of Staff Dr. MacCormick, the  COO, the Chief Executive RN & a HR representative.

So, a little more information has come to light.

There were 2 emergency staff meetings called earlier in the day at Scripps Encinitas. Usually these meetings are held when there is a big case of something going wrong–like a wrongful death. The meetings were held to discuss “the recent events concerning a staff member”. From what I’ve heard from staff that were present at the meetings, nothing was discussed other than the issue is a confidential matter.

It came to my attention late last night from someone that there are 4 doctors that are on a medical board of the hospital that are responsible for suspending Dr. Biter. They are:

Dr. Ronald MacCormick, Chief of Staff
354 Santa Fe Dr. Encinitas, CA 92024
760-633-6807 fax 760-633-6807

Dr. James La Belle, Internal Medicine
354 Santa Fe Dr, Encinitas, CA 92024
760-633-7686

Dr. Thomas Chippendale, Neurology
320 Santa Fe Dr Ste 101 Encinitas, CA 92024
760-942-1390

Dr. Michael Lobatz, Neurology
320 Santa Fe Dr. Ste 108 Encinitas, CA 92024
760-942-1390

Please send letters to these people since they are the ones that have decided to suspend Dr. Biter. With this public outcry, they need to reinstate him immediately. They need to know that it’s not their call, that it’s our call & we are demanding to have Dr. Biter & that they can’t bully him or us. This bullying won’t be tolerated. Thank you for all of the letters you are writing! My email box has been inundated with letters. If you sent me a letter & asked me a question or wrote me something, I want you to know that I haven’t even opened them yet. I’ve been so busy. So if you have an important question or issue, please email me & let me know. Thanks for understanding.

It is also interesting that Dr. MacCormick (& Dr. Fenton–Head of OB) will make money off of Dr. Biter’s suspension IF moms in labor come into Scripps Encinitas & use the hospitalists (on-call OBs) because guess who owns the hospitalist company? Dr. MacCormick! Isn’t that a conflict of interest?

A group of 5 pregnant moms, 2 husbands & I went at 3 pm yesterday (Wed) to Scripps Encinitas to request a meeting with Dr. MacCormick, Chief of Staff. We were surprised that he came back on campus to meet with us along with the COO, the Chief Executive RN & someone from HR. The statement they made is that the issue is confidential & they are not at liberty to share any information. They are sympathetic to the situation & understand that it is a stressful situation for the pregnant couples, but there is nothing that they can share. Dr. MacCormick stated that the hospital has made provisions for their OB hospitalists (on call OBs) to care for the pregnant moms when they go into labor & that he fully trusts in their ability to support their birth plans. One of the moms took the lead & stated that we were there to get answers but understood that it was a legal issue & that we might not get answers. She said that we also just wanted to be heard & have our opinions shared with them. She stated that we all know that Dr. Biter was delivering babies as of Thursday & delivered a baby on Friday that had meconium aspiration that was discovered at the time of birth. She stated that the baby is doing fine & that meconium aspiration is something that is fairly common. So, why was it that he was delivering babies Thursday & Friday but them as of Friday afternoon, was deemed to be too dangerous to deliver any more babies? They couldn’t comment on that because it is a confidential issue. Several of the moms spoke & some cried about how emotionally stressful this situation has been on them & they have developed strong ties to Dr. Biter & can’t & won’t consider birthing with anyone else. A dad shared that they’ve been building a relationship with Dr. Biter the past 31 weeks & they trust him & know that he will honor their wishes for a natural birth for their birth. He said that it’s their 1st birth & they really want it to be a wonderful experience. He said that he knows that Dr. Biter will provide that for them and that they will be loyal to him wherever he goes. One of the moms shared that they recently moved to San Diego. They are in the military & chose to go outside of the military hospital to birth their 2nd child because they had a negative birth experience the 1st time. She researched & learned that Scripps Encinitas was supposed to be the most natural-birth supportive hospital in town. She called the Labor & Delivery dept to get a recommendation for a great OB & the nurse said that she’d have to give 3 referrals but that Dr. Biter got a “gold star”. This mom said that she specifically chose their hospital & this doctor because she wants a better birth. She said that she is committed to having Dr. Biter be at her birth & that she was really unhappy with the decision to suspend him. I shared that I’m a childbirth educator & have had over 350 couples come through my classes. I’ve always referred my clients to Scripps Encinitas because they promote themselves to be the most natural-birth supportive & because they are a mother-baby friendly hospital. I asked them how they could be either of those if they continue getting rid of natural birth supportive care providers like the midwives & Dr. Biter, who is the MOST natural-birth supportive OB in town. They were defensive about the midwives & wanted to clarify that they didn’t make the midwife group leave, but that the midwife group left on their own accord. I stated that they technically may have left, but it was only because the environment was hostile & that we all really knew what happened. I suggested to them that they rethink their decision to suspend Dr. Biter because in doing so, they’ve now tainted their reputation as a natural-birth supportive & mother-baby friendly hospital. In suspending him, they’ve also put themselves in a poor financial situation because almost all of his patients will follow him or choose other hospitals. I shared with them that I was aware of 5 moms that were due & chose to have homebirths with midwives & that NO ONE has chosen to birth in Scripps Encinitas with the on-call doctors since the suspension occurred. The COO & the Chief Exec. RN were defensive again saying that I shouldn’t make blanket statements that include their nurses because their nurses are mother-baby friendly & natural-birth supportive. Dr. MacCormick also stated that there are other OBs on staff who support natural birth & will respect a woman’s birth plan. I then stated that I used to refer clients to several other doctors who say they support natural birth only to find that my couples consistently would report back to me that they were pressured & didn’t have the birth experience they wanted. Yet, every client that went to Dr. Biter for their birth had only positive things to say about their birth experiences. So, they may say they have other doctors, but as they can see, the group of people before them would NOT be coming to their hospital unless Dr. Biter was present. A dad, who is also a doctor, ended the meeting by saying that this small group represents the larger group of Dr. Biter patients & that most if not all of Dr. Biter’s patients would not be coming to the hospital to birth their babies. The dad requested that they reinstate Dr. Biter immediately so the women in the room could birth where they wanted to & with the OB they desired & developed a relationship with. The dad requested that the decision be made as soon as possible & that if they weren’t going to reinstate him, that that decision be made as soon as possible as well. We thanked them all for their time & they did the same. They repeated that they are sympathetic to the situation & that they heard our requests.

Here’s the latest information we have about the rally:

We are expecting over 500 people to come to the rally [Friday, May 14th, 2010]. Please do NOT park on Scripps property. There is a parking lot across the street & residential parking west of the hospital.

If you’d like to order a t-shirt that says Bring Dr. Biter Back!, please contact Deanna at opporders@gmail.com for details.

Here are the new recommendations for signs:
STOP BULLYING BITER!
Bring Dr. Biter Back!
Bring Biter Back!
Dr. Biter IS Mother-Baby Friendly!
www.BRINGBITERBACK.com
Dr. Biter is THE VBAC doc!
Dr. Biter has the lowest C-section rate!
RNs (heart) Dr. Biter
Biter is the only OB that teaches surgery in San Diego!
Best DOCTOR 2 years in a row!
Reinstate Dr. Biter NOW!
My baby needs Dr. Biter!
My birth needs Dr. Biter!
Dr. Biter respects women’s rights!

We want this rally to be positive but we also want to make our point. Please keep your signs focused on what we want–Dr. Biter to be reinstated immediately–and what we love about Dr. Biter.

Feel free to contact the news–TV, radio, online, & print–to encourage them to cover this story & our rally. John Gardner’s sentencing is scheduled to happen at 1:30 pm so they will be covering that, but we’ll be rallying until 3:30 pm, so they can still come cover our rally. If they need a contact person, you can refer them to me: Carol Yeh-Garner 858-837-1259 or to Sheri Menelli: 760-522-2829.

On behalf of all of the people working behind the scenes to make this rally happen & to help get Dr. Biter reinstated, we THANK YOU for your support!

Be Sociable, Share!

•