definition decision

Study finds that women choose the mode of delivery preferred by their doctor

Update: Metz (2013) came to the same conclusion of Bernstein (2012).  Metz concluded, “Less than one third of the good candidates for TOLAC [trial of labor after cesarean] chose TOLAC. Managing provider influences this decision.”  Read more here.


The findings of “Trial of labor after previous cesarean section versus repeat cesarean section: are patients making an informed decision?” presented at the February 9, 2012 annual meeting of the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine’s, The Pregnancy Meeting ™, in Dallas, Texas is not surprising.  Doctors have so much influence over patients and apparently, patients are making medical decisions without a basic understanding the benefits and risks of their options.

“Even though most women can achieve a vaginal delivery with trial of labor, less than 10 percent of them attempt to do so,” said Sarah Bernstein, MD, with St. Luke’s-Roosevelt Hospital Center, Obstetrics and Gynecology, in New York, and one of the study’s authors. “In fact, when patients perceived that their doctor preferred a repeat cesarean, very few chose to undergo trial of labor, whereas the majority chose trial of labor if that was their doctor’s preference.”

The study was a survey provided to women upon admission for their elective repeat cesarean section (ERCS) or trial of labor after cesarean section (TOLAC).  I am really shocked at the level of knowledge most of the women had. 73% of the women admitted for a ERCS did not know the chances of a successful VBAC and 64% did not know the risk of uterine rupture.  54% of women choosing a TOLAC did not know the chances of a successful VBAC and 45% did not know the risk of rupture!  WOW!!

Women in both groups demonstrated lack of knowledge on the risks and benefits of TOLAC and ERCS, particularly women in the ERCS group. Specifically, patients were not familiar with the chances of a successful TOLAC, the effect of indication for previous CS on success, the risk of uterine rupture, and the increase in risk with each successive CS.  Only 13% of TOLAC patients and 4% of ERCS patients knew the chances for a successful TOLAC, while the majority in both groups stated that they “did not know”.  The majority (64%)of ERCS patients did not know the risk of uterine rupture during TOLAC and 52% did not know which delivery mode had a faster recovery time.

This is why, even if you are on the fence about VBAC vs. repeat cesarean, selecting a care provider who is genuinely supportive of VBAC gives you the power of choice.  Read more on what makes a supportive care provider here.

Read the press release and a news article.  The abstract is available on page 3 of this PDF.

Quickly and easily provide the resources for VBAC information with the FAQ card.


Bernstein, S., Matalon-Grazi, S., & Rosenn, B. (2012). Trial of labor after previous cesarean section versus repeat cesarean section: are patients making an informed decision? Supplement to JANUARY 2012 American Journal of Obstetrics & Gynecology, S21. Retrieved from

6 thoughts on “Study finds that women choose the mode of delivery preferred by their doctor

  1. Pingback: Maternity Manifesto – Better Beginnings

  2. victor

    My name is victor my wife having a problem for pregnancy I go meaning peace looking for help I don’t see help, until see this men sabon sprit doctor he now have the solution on the problem that I face, for over 4year to 10year my wife she is pregnancy drsabon now give me mercy for that, over one month my wife she now pregnant me and family happy, today I have a baby boy now person that need help he or she contact me drsabonspelltmple thank you.

    1. Jen Kamel Post author


      I’m so sorry, I don’t understand your question. Could you ask it again?



  3. Sam

    When I found out I was pregnant with our 2nd I called my previous midwife and she told be I could not be a client and I would have to have a c-setion because my son was a c-section. Well, I did my home work, got a new midwife and gave birth to a beautiful 10lb, 10oz baby girl at home. If I had listened to her I would have had an unnecessary surgery. You really need to advocate for yourself. I second hiring a doula! 🙂

  4. Jillian

    My doctor is on the fence although I sense an anti-VBAC attitude (little does he know I am getting midwife care for the last 4 weeks and driving 8 hours to have TOLAC). I am awfully and easily swayed in labour and I CANNOT handle any possible pressure from him.

  5. Pingback: A Little Weekend Reading: Part Two (a.k.a. ‘Sunday’) | Empowered Birth

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *